Welcome to our MP3 Player Review Page:
2009/2010 UPDATE: This article was originally written a few years ago, and with electronic devices continually changing, it can be tough to keep everything current. But here goes...Obviously the Apple iPod is the best-selling and most popular MP3 player by far, commanding something like 80% of the market. Their ongoing upgrades have brought us the iPod Touch (basically the iPhone without the phone capabilities) and access to not only music but also video, games, "apps", and Internet access. Microsoft launched the Zune in 2006 and is now in its 4th iteration. Other players in the MP3 business include Sandisk (with their Sansa players) and Creative Labs (with their Zen models, some of which have similar fancy features like touch screens). You can save some money buying from Sandisk or Creative Labs, but given the over-reaching influence of Apple iTunes, Apps, and overall usability, my recommendation would be to stick with Apple, or the Zune if you are anti-Apple for some reason. Amazon maintains an up-to-date list of the bestselling MP3 players - it's a good starting point to see what products and prices are out there.
In terms of which iPod is best for you, there are basically 4 models to choose from. As mentioned above, the iPod Touch looks and functions like the iPhone, except it doesn't make phone calls. It uses flash memory with capacities ranging from 8GB to 64GB, and you pay more for more memory (the cheapest is about $190, while the most expensive is just under $400, ouch!). What you get is a big player with a big screen, that plays music and movies, along with video games and thousands of other "apps" available from iTunes. And it can connect to the Internet via WiFi to gives you access to email and web browsing, maps, etc. as well. So if you are not looking for a tiny little player, the iTouch is our pick as the best since it is so versatile. If you want something smaller, the "classic" iPods are still available as well. The iPod Classic is the one with the famous scroll wheel on the front and a smaller display screen, while the Nano is just a fraction of the size, the orginial mini MP3 player, and the iPod Shuffle is the ultra-tiny clip-on model with no screen, just music. The iPod Classics are the only model that uses a small hard drive for storage instead of flash memory, so they have higher capacity (store more stuff). So if you really need to carry 100GB+ of music and movies around with you, it's probably the model you need. If I wasn't getting the iTouch, I'd probably go with a Nano because it is so small and portable, while still capable enough to handle music and movies/videos.
OLD CONTENT FOLLOWS
What are the best MP3 Players I can buy? iPod? Sony?
Now that CDs and tapes are officially dead, MP3 music is the way to go. MP3 songs are just a special electronic file format for digitized music, allowing you to store and playback songs on your computer, portable MP3 players (like the famous iPod), your car stereo, or home stereo. So what MP3 Players are best? Depends on what your music needs are. MP3 players comes in 3 main sizes/categories right now: flash memory based, micro hard drive based, and normal hard drive based.
Let's start with the normal hard drive based MP3 players. A little larger than a deck of cards, these music machines contain a small hard drive inside, like the ones found in laptop computers. The Apple iPod has pretty much owned this category. These players come with capacities ranging from 20-60 gigabytes (GB). An average MP3 song takes up about 3 or 4 megabytes (MB), so that means you can hold about 250 songs per gigabyte, or 5000 songs on a 20GB player. Obviously, most of us don't have more than 5000 mp3 songs in our music collections - so people like Apple are adding additional functions to their players, like the ability to store and display color photos.
A 20 GB iPod can be yours for around $275, while the 60GB iPod Photo is more like $400. A number of other companies also make this style of MP3 Player. The Creative Labs Zen Touch (40GB about $250) is a sturdy, excellent sounding player. The Dell DJ-20 comes in at under $200 for 20GB of storage. But given all the accessories available for the iPod and its dominant market position, your best bet is going with an iPod (and they work fine on Windows computers as well).
Micro Hard Drive MP3 players
While a deck of cards is small for most of us, of course in the world of micro-electronics, smaller is better. Hence, there is another family of smaller players than contain mini/micro hard drives with 4-6 GB capacity, good for carrying about 800-1500 songs in your shirt pocket. A little lighter, a little smaller, these players are great if you are not concerned with storing thousands and thousands of songs. Again, the leader in this category is the iPod Mini (6 GB, around $200, 18 hours of playback time!). Practically feather-lite in your hand (3.6oz), you can easily strap it to your arm or throw it in a pocket to go jogging, to the gym, etc. All the Apple products use the iTunes software for managing, storing, and syncing your music collection between your PC and your MP3 player. The Rio Carbon (5GB) is a cheaper alternative at about $129, and it gets great reviews for both functionality and sound qaulity.The Creative Zen Micro (5 GB, about $189) is another alternative, but again, with Apple's dominant position in this field as well, the iPod mini is generally the safest best.
Flash Memory MP3 players
The final category is the flash memory based mp3 players. Flash memory is just specialized computer memory chips used to store information. Unlike a hard drive, there are no moving parts, so they use less energy and can be even smaller in size. MP3 players using flash memory commonly come in 512KB (about 120 songs) or 1GB (about 250 songs). Many are the size of a butane lighter or even smaller. Of course Apple has a $99 product in this field called the iPod shuffle. In this case, we'd say avoid the Apple. With no LCD screen for viewing song names or playlists, you basically load on some songs and push the NEXT SONG button and that's it. Samsung offers the YEPP 1GB for around $130 (pictured at left). The YEPP uses standard AA batteries and includes an FM radio built-in - not bad. Throw excellent sound quality on top of that, and you have a great choice for an mp3 player. Creative Labs also make the tiny MuVo and Nomad players, good sound, good price, not a bad option. Sandisk makes the Digital Audio Players, with 15 hours of playback on a AAA battery (Cruzer Micro $90 for 512MB, 1GB $125). Last but not least, the Cowon iAudio U2 player (1.2 oz) is a newcomer. Connects to your PC with a USB cable, you can drag and drop files onto it. It records, has an FM tuner, and runs for about 15 hours on its lithium battery. At about $150 for the 1GB model, this might be your best bet.
Do you have a quality site or product that belongs in this guide? We are always happy to evaluate or review new products and websites. Feel free to contact us at the email address below and let us know about you. If you have a demo product you'd like us to look at, please contact us before sending anything. Thank you.