Updated: June 8, 2015

Bagel Slicer Reviews:

Buying a Better Bagel Slicer - Making lunch shouldn't be dangerous, but everyone knows how hard it is to get a nice even cut in a bagel, and wonders what commercial slicer bagel shops must use to get that even surface on their sandwiches. Most people don't realize that bagel cutting is hazardous for many people; no less a publication than the Wall Street Journal ran a story stating that improper bagel cutting is responsible for the fifth most knife injuries in the United States every year! Looking at it from that angle, it makes sense; bagels are hard and slippery at the same time, a round hazard just waiting to happen. That makes a great bagel slicer an important safety feature in your kitchen as well. Who makes bagel slicers? Are they convenient to use, wash, and store? What different types of bagel slicers are out on the market? We're going to take a look below!


Best Bagel Slicer:

Most Popular Bagel Slicer - As mentioned in that Wall Street Journal article, the most popular bagel slicer ever invented is the Bagel Guillotine. Invented 18 years ago, this product is more than just a cool name. It makes bagel slicing easy, safe, and even fun. You execute the action manually by placing the bagel in a plastic vice, then pushing down on the handle. A wide base keeps the Guillotine in place as the bagel awaits its doom, and the acrylic guards ensure that no one's hand or finger is ever close to the blade. Moving 80,000 units a year, it's pretty obvious that the functionality, appearance, name, and safety features of this bagel slicer appeal well to the buying public (and let's face it, anyone who has been cut while slicing a bagel likes the idea of justice that this product represents). However, the Bagel Guillotine is not the only game in town; at around $25 it's a great buy, but there are competitors who seek to sell their models based on what they hope are more appealing designs and conveniences. You can browse the best selling bagel slicers online here.


Heavy Duty Bagel Slicers:

If you are looking for a good commercial bagel slicer for a small company or because you eat an awful lot of bagels at home, you are looking at more of the same kind of products. Larien makes what it labels the commercial bagel slicer in the Bagel Biter, but this is really no different than the Bagel Guillotine, with a few extra layers of plastic around the base. Models such as Ironwood's Bagel Miter are also more heavy duty takes on traditional bagel slicer designs. On the other hand, electric bagel cutters may have a future for those who have to cut a lot of bagels in a day. The Chef's Choice 680 Bagel Pro electric bagel slicer is bulky and hard to clean, but it can slice a lot of bagels quickly and with no real human effort; you just feed the bagels in and away it goes. However, like a lot of electric slicing products, electric bagel slicers tend to jam easily, and are a real pain to take apart for clearing that jam and as we mentioned earlier, to clean. Not to mention that at $45 and up, electric bagel slicers are more than double the price of many of the manual models. When it comes to the convenience, safety, and design of the best bagel slicer, we definitely recommend sticking with an easier to use and much less expensive manual bagel slicer.

Alternative Bagel Slicer Designs:

One of the drawbacks of the Bagel Guillotine and its many copycats is that it does tend to take up a lot of space on a countertop or in a cupboard or drawer, and it is not very easy to clean. And of course there is all that manual labor which we will get to in a second. Competing bagel slicer manufacturers suggest that maybe a more natural design is best in a bagel slicer. Enter the Brooklyn Bagel Slicer, the other subject of the Wall Street Journal article. This device is something that people without a knowledge of the French Revolution will be more familiar with; it looks just like a knife! In fact, that is exactly what the Brooklyn Bagel Slicer is; a serrated knife enclosed in plastic. That plastic allows a person to wield the slicer in their hand in a natural motion without worrying about cutting themselves. It's easy to wash and store, and you don't have to take anything apart. Cooking.com and Realfoodliving.com rate it as the best bagel slicer on the market for both home and light commercial bagel slicing because of its natural ease. Realfoodliving.com also notes that unlike the guillotine models and even electric bagel slicers, the Brooklyn has no trouble cutting through denser, whole wheat bagels preferred by the health conscious. If you don't mind a bulkier bagel slicer which is a bit harder to wash but don't like the barbaric design of the Guillotine, you might be interested in a few dozen other bagel slicer designs. Products such as the Bagelpod are actually great conversation pieces, and they hold the bagel in place while you press down on the blade handle for a great, even cut. On the other hand, if you like to vary up the size of your bagels these total encasing bagel slicers might not work the best for you. You can also check out plain vice type bagel holders such as those made by Fox Run. They don't come with a knife so they are cheaper at around $9, they are just designed to hold a bagel in place.