Updated: November 2017

Yogurt Maker Reviews:

Making yogurt at home is easier than ever before and the new yogurt makers from Salton are the most popular on the market. I have always bought yogurt in the store and was definitely a little scared with the idea of homemade yogurt. My wife was recently at a friends house and came home telling me all about the yogurt she had that was homemade and really tasty. The yogurt maker her friend has is the Salton YM9 1-Quart Machine - the top selling and most expensive model on the market. There are starter yogurt makers available in stores that are more like $40 to $75 which also rate quite high amongst consumers. We did our research by reading consumer reviews on websites like Cooking.com, Amazon.com, Epinions, and in blogs related to yogurt machines/makers. The information in the owner reviews was the most helpful and ultimately we went with the Salton Yogurt Maker as well since the feedback and praise were so positive on that model.
yogurt machine

Buying Guide - Just what should you look for in a yogurt maker? First, let's start with the top brands - Easiyo, Salton, Yogourmet, Donvier, Euro Cuisine, Waring Pro, Yolife and Cuisipro. They are sold in stores like Walmart, Target, and Sears in the kitchen appliance section. You can also find them online at websites like Amazon.com or Cooking.com. What size yogurt maker is best? You will find that most machines will make 1 quart of yogurt although you can find 2 quart makers like the Yogourmet Multi. We say stick with the 1 quart variety unless everyone in the family agrees on the same type of yogurt. Otherwise you may end up with too much and waste it. Capacity is a big consideration, but more importantly is how the yogurt is configured in the machine. I prefer the single containers that are larger - it makes the production much easier. Your other option are the yogurt makers that use 6 to 8 single serve jars in the fermentation process. If those in your household can agree upon the same flavor (ingredients), then the larger container makes sense. For those with varying tastes, the smaller serve jars allow you to mix up different starter cultures. A machine like the Waring YM350 Professional is one of the few that lets you make yogurt in either 8 oz or 16 oz jars and gives you a wide range on serving sizes. Some people really like frozen yogurt and for the most part the machines we have listed below are best for refrigerated yogurt, not the frozen variety. The Salton YM9 Yogurt Maker is one exception to the rule since the fermentation container is freezer safe. The electric yogurt makers are best for consistent results and many have timers to tell you when the incubation is done. The Easiyo is slightly different in that it uses boiling water to heat up the incubator and keep a constant temperature for fermentation. Reviews are positive for the Easiyo yogurt maker so don't rule this one out. Almost all the yogurt maker reviews we read were really positive and owners said the machines worked great. That being said, the Salton took top honors on several sites and the Euro Cuisine YM100 was another top seller with favorable reviews too. Browse the top selling yogurt makers online here.

Best Yogurt Maker:

RECOMMENDED - No matter what website or store you look in for a yogurt maker, the Salton YM9 1-Quart Yogurt Maker is the clear winner in expert reviews and consumer opinions. I would say the only drawback is the high price ($140), but the pros outweigh the cost in almost every other way. The 1 quart capacity is perfect and the internal container is freezer safe meaning you can make frozen yogurt as well. The unit features a temperature controlled incubator so fermentation is nearly the same each and every time you make a batch of homemade yogurt. The Salton YM9 is easy to use and making 1 quart of yogurt takes roughly 4 to 10 yours. The longer it goes the more tart the flavor. Making yogurt is simple and you can add your favorite ingredients like nuts or fruits. The recipe book that comes with the Salton is a great place to get ideas for all the types of yogurt you can make. Owner comments include "reliable and energy efficient" and "foolproof even for the novice yogurt makers out there". We have found it to be a delight to use and my wife has turned me into a homemade yogurt type of guy. See all the most popular yogurt makers online here.

Electric Yogurt Maker:

With over 100 positive reviews - we think the Cuisipro Donvier Electronic Yogurt Maker is another excellent option is the Salton is too much. The Cuisipro is priced to sell at around $50 and this model gets top reviews for electric yogurt makers on Amazon. Makes up to 6 cups of homemade yogurt and you can create 8 different flavors. Owners say the digital display and electric trimer keep the controls and process simple. Includes a 5 and 10 minute warning beep and also features an auto shut off. Comes with a heater base, a thermometer stirrer, 8 jars w/ lids, unit cover, and a manual. The Donvier yogurt maker is designed well and works great. We found a few negative reviews, but one was because the price is too much - at $50 this is a bargain compared to the Salton listed above. The Euro Cuisine YM100 Automatic Yogurt Maker and the Waring Pro YM350 Professional Yogurt Maker get similar owner feedback and are priced between $40 and $50 so for comparison reasons take a look at those too.

Basic Yogurt Maker:

As mentioned above, not all yogurt makers need electricity to work. The Easiyo Yogurt Maker is only $25 and runs on boiling water to ferment the culture. Makes up to 1 quart of homemade yogurt and owners say the process is really quite easy to do. Of the reviews listed on Amazon, 12 of the 15 listed gave this machine 5 out of 5 stars. Owners say you get consistent results of great tasting yogurt without too much effort involved.